| Customer Reviews: Average Rating:  Rating : - Love The Band, but the flaws in this film - and DVD version - can't be ignored Let me just preface that I am a huge fan of The Band. I always preferred them to bands like Grateful Dead. Levon Helm's voice came straight out of the smoky, Civil War-era hills. While this movie looks good and sounds good, the abundance of post-gig doctoring (overdubs) hampers this document, in my book. Watch the left hand of the late, great bassist Rick Danko (RIP) during the Eric Clapton song - the shot where Danko is left (closest to the camera), with Robertson in the middle and Clapton on the right (background). Danko's hand (both of them, actually) don't match the sound. According to Levon Helm, the film was riddled with overdubs, but not by Helm. In Helm's autobiography, he talks about how he refused to record overdubs for his drumming and his voice for the movie. While I'm sure that much of the soundtrack is live, there's a good portion that isn't (much of it is evidenced by Danko's hands; curiously, Robertson's back or side is aimed at the camera for some of his soloing, too, which might raise some suspicion, although his frontal shots seem live), and for a musician, watching their hands not matching up to the sonics, well, it's a flaw that dampens the experience. I know almost every live album and DVD has some post-production tampering, but "The Last Waltz" has too many blatant examples. And speaking of the visuals, what is up with this DVD version's crop job? Originally, Scorsese's film crew, despite all the coke, did a pretty decent job of framing the musicians with the cameras, although now the fake letterboxing mat (black bars slapped onto the top and bottom of an already cropped, if not completely pan-and-scan/full-frame image, render Danko's bass and Robertson's guitar invisible for way too long. Here's hoping that a true widescreen version of this - and Pink Floyd's "Live at Pompeii" - is reissued on DVD, with the full film negative image on the disc. Again, I love The Band. They - and The Band's fans - a DVD reissue done right. :) + See Full Customer Review |  |